As summer approaches, it brings the tantalising scent of smoky BBQ goodness into the air, but it also brings something else, a question that many BBQ lovers will debate: which is better? Gas or Charcoal?
It’s an age old question, and you’ll find enthusiasts on both sides. One such enthusiast, Hank Hill, from Mike Judge’s cult animated series King of The Hill is one of the most famous examples of a gas BBQ lover. He is a propane (and propane accessories) salesman, so he might be a little biased, but his company’s slogan “taste the meat, not the heat” can ring true.
What this means is that gas BBQs give you better control over heat, meaning you’re less likely to completely chargrill things black as you might do if you have little cooking experience and use a charcoal BBQ.
But that doesn’t make gas barbecues the instant winner; however, there are plenty of pros and cons to each. So, if you’re in the market for a new grill, let’s look into things further and unravel the great debate…
Gas BBQ: Who Is It For?
Gas BBQs are for those who value convenience and versatility. As mentioned above, you have more control over the heat settings. This is ideal for those who aren’t as confident with cooking.
Featuring user friendly features, you can start cooking on a gas BBQ almost immediately. The level of control you get reduces the risk of overcooking or undercooking food. It’s clear to see why these are a popular choice with many BBQ lovers.
With the additional temperature control, it is easier to cook delicate foods like fish, and get steak just right.
Gas BBQs also usually feature a wide range of accessories, add ons and attachments such as rotisseries. This versatility is great if you’ll be BBQing frequently. Gas BBQs are also considered easier to clean than charcoal models.
Though they are usually more of an investment cost wise, fuel can be more efficient. But this may depend on how often you cook. The speed of cooking can also be great for those with less time or for an impromptu gathering.
Gas BBQs are also seen as cleaner burning and therefore having less of an impact on the environment. However, some charcoal grilling enthusiasts argue that the use of sustainable charcoal made from renewable sources, such as coconut shells or bamboo, can mitigate the environmental impact to some extent.
Charcoal BBQ: Who Is It For?
If gas BBQs are so easy to use, then why would anyone pick a charcoal one? The authentic smoke infused taste of course!
With ample amounts of patience and perhaps a bit of practice, your extra efforts will be rewarded with a charcoal BBQ.
Charcoal BBQs can achieve a higher heat than gas grills, making them great for getting the perfect sear on thick cuts of meat, as well as adding a charred crust that people are guaranteed to love.
You can also experiment with different types of wood chips, adding more layers of flavour to your food.
Charcoal BBQs are usually cheaper to buy upfront than gas BBQs, though it’s worth noticing that the cost of fuel may work out more in the long run. But as mentioned before, it all depends on how often you plan on barbecuing anyway, if it’s just the occasional small gathering on a leisurely weekend, charcoal is a great choice.
To Sum Up
Choose Gas BBQ if:
- Convenience is a top priority, and you prefer quick and hassle-free ignition.
- You want precise temperature control for versatile cooking.
- Minimal cleanup and maintenance are preferred.
Choose Charcoal BBQ if:
- Authentic smoky flavour and the ritual of charcoal grilling are essential to you.
- Achieving a perfect sear and char on meats is a top priority.
- You enjoy a slower, more leisurely grilling process.
There’s Always Hybrid
If the pros of each barbecue type sound good to you, then the good news is you don’t have to choose one or the other. You can always consider investing in a hybrid barbecue model.
If you want easier cooking with a classic barbecue taste, they’re definitely worth looking into.
Final Thoughts
In the gas vs. charcoal BBQ debate, there is no clear winner – both options have their unique advantages and appeal to different grilling enthusiasts.
So whether it’s a gas BBQ’s convenience or a charcoal BBQ’s traditional taste, you can’t really go wrong other than what your own personal preferences dictate.
So now you know what each has to offer, you can choose your new BBQ with confidence.